18 American-Italian recipes that feel like a cozy Sunday dinner
American-Italian cooking blends traditional Italian flavors with hearty, comforting dishes that have become favorites in kitchens everywhere. Rich sauces, cheesy baked pastas, and flavorful meats come together to create meals that feel both nostalgic and satisfying. These American-Italian recipes celebrate the classics that families have loved for years and continue to make again and again.
Chicken Parmesan Subs
You’re going to love these amazing chicken parmesan subs which pair fresh bread with crispy chicken, gooey cheese and warmed marinara sauce.
Get the Recipe: Chicken Parmesan Subs
Chicken Riggies
This chicken riggies recipe is creamy, spicy and packed with flavor. It’s a bold pasta dish ideal for weeknight dinners or special occasions.
Get the Recipe: Chicken Riggies
Steak Marsala
Steak marsala is a hearty, savory dish with juicy steak and a rich marsala wine sauce. It’s simple to prepare and packed with amazing flavor.
Get the Recipe: Steak Marsala
Shrimp Francese
Shrimp francese features lightly battered shrimp in a buttery lemon and white wine sauce for a bright, rich Italian-American favorite.
Get the Recipe: Shrimp Francese
Shrimp Oreganata
Shrimp oreganata features juicy shrimp baked with garlicky breadcrumbs, oregano, butter and lemon for a flavorful Italian-inspired meal.
Get the Recipe: Shrimp Oreganata
Easy Stromboli
Easy Italian stromboli is a flavor-packed pizza roll made with pizza dough, various Italian deli meats, cheeses, seasoning, and herbs.
Get the Recipe: Easy Stromboli
Mostaccioli
This mostaccioli bake layers pasta with Italian sausage, marinara, ricotta, and mozzarella for a cheesy, cozy casserole that feeds a crowd.
Get the Recipe: Mostaccioli
Slow Cooker Italian Beef
This slow cooker Italian beef is an easy dinner recipe. With just a few simple ingredients, turn a crockpot beef recipe into tasty sandwiches.
Get the Recipe: Slow Cooker Italian Beef
Cioppino
This cioppino recipe brings the taste of the ocean to your dinner table. Perfect for any occasion, it’s a great dish for seafood fans.
Get the Recipe: Cioppino
Creamy Tuscan Sausage Pasta
Rich, creamy and perfectly satisfying, this cozy and creamy Tuscan sausage pasta makes a wonderful midweek dinner that the family will love.
Get the Recipe: Creamy Tuscan Sausage Pasta
Chicken Scarpariello
Bold flavors shine in this Italian-American dish, where tender chicken, sausage, and peppers simmer in a tangy-sweet sauce for a hearty meal.
Get the Recipe: Chicken Scarpariello
Italian Love Cake
This delicious Italian love cake combines chocolate cake with ricotta filling and pudding topping for a rich and creamy layered dessert.
Get the Recipe: Italian Love Cake
Pesto Tortellini Pasta Salad
Pesto tortellini pasta salad is tossed with fresh veggies and bold basil pesto. A quick and easy recipe for potlucks, picnics or lunches.
Get the Recipe: Pesto Tortellini Pasta Salad
Manicotti
Cheesy, creamy spinach-stuffed manicotti topped with marinara, this classic Italian-American dish is homemade comfort food at its finest.
Get the Recipe: Manicotti
Italian Stuffed Meat Rolls
What a versatile drink Mott’s Clamato is. I created these Italian Stuffed Meat Rolls in Mott’s Clamato. I never knew how easily I could…
Get the Recipe: Italian Stuffed Meat Rolls
Cheesy Italian Chicken Pasta Bake
My family loves this cheesy Italian chicken pasta bake recipe. It’s also great for any potluck dinner or for company. Try and enjoy!
Get the Recipe: Cheesy Italian Chicken Pasta Bake
Red Pesto Potatoes
These extremely easy Red Pesto Potatoes make an excellent side dish for many entrees. With basically five ingredients and two being…
Get the Recipe: Red Pesto Potatoes
Cheesy Million Dollar Pasta
This Million Dollar Baked Penne is a family favorite! The homemade sauce is incredible and the hidden layer of creamy/cheesiness is to live for!
Get the Recipe: Cheesy Million Dollar Pasta
